Best Beekeeping Practices – Replacing Your Old Combs

Many US beekeepers do not routinely replace their old combs. Older beekeeping books suggest that combs be reused to save money and energy that bees could use to make honey instead of wax. It is not unusual to find beekeepers who have combs that are over thirty years old.

In the wake of Colony Collapse Disorder, bee experts are recommending that combs be replaced more frequently. Dr. Marla Spivak of the University of Minnesota Department of Entomology recommends that comb should be replaced every 5-7 years. In Europe, it is recommended that combs be replaced every three years. In the UK, my beekeeping friends Emily Heath and Emma Sarah Tennant replace their combs annually.

Why the change? We now know that bees wax absorbs pesticides, both those used for treatment within the hive and those used in agriculture. Old combs may also retain disease spores, such as foulbrood and Nosema. American Foulbrood spores can remain viable in combs for as long as thirty-five years. Replacing combs may also be helpful in managing varroa mites.

Old Bee Comb

It is easy to tell when comb needs replacing. It appears dark brown or even black in color. A good rule of thumb is to hold the frame up to the light. It should be replaced if light cannot be seen through it. The comb above looks very old.

There are three major ways to replace old comb: the Rotation Method, the Bailey Method and the Shook Swarm Technique.

The Rotation Method is the simplest, and the one I use.  At the beginning of spring, when it is warm enough to separate the brood nest, remove the two outer frames from the box, which should be empty. Insert two new frames into the center of the box and move the frames left of center to the left and the frames right of center to the right. This will give you a full rotation every five years in a ten frame box.

In my next post, I will describe the Bailey Method and the Shook Swarm Technique.

9 thoughts on “Best Beekeeping Practices – Replacing Your Old Combs

  1. mossandivy says:

    Wonderful Post- thanks!

  2. Emily Heath says:

    Thanks for linking to my blog 🙂 That’s a great pic of old black comb you’ve found. We’re going to be doing our shook-swarm before the end of March.

    • You will have to let me know how it goes!!
      I think it’s important for US beekeepers to know more about hygienic practices. And we wonder why our colonies die off..

  3. The only thing I know about bees is that when I was young I was stung by a bee…and now I know honey combs should be removed from a hive periodically. Thanks for sharing your knowledge. We are considering keeping bees to help pollinate our garden, but we don’t know where to begin. Can you recommend a good book?

    • I started with “Beekeeping For Dummies” and I recommend it wholeheartedly. There are lots of good beekeeping books out there, but this one tells you all you need to know in a very reassuring manner.

      I’m so glad you are considering keeping bees! It’s lots of fun, and so helpful to our environment!!

  4. This is a great post explaining why there’s good incentive to replace comb regularly, particularly in the brood. Our bees seem to enjoy the spring clean and the challenge each year – we’ll be blow-torching last year’s brood boxes to kill off any disease and making the new frames for the shook swarm in a couple of weeks. Very exciting! Thank you for linking to my blog 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s